Cuba health and education hollowed out as staff join emigration exodus | Cuba


Every morning before dawn, hundreds of people line up outside the US embassy. At midday this particular day, Acelia De La Osa, a 71-year-old retired physics teacher with frizzy hair, bounds out of the sleek modernist building and hugs her daughter. They both laugh with tears in their eyes: Acelia’s got a visa and will soon be in Florida.

Her daughter, Ana Delia, the only one of her siblings left on the island, also hopes to get out once her visa comes through. An intensive care nurse, she has seen her salary’s purchasing power – now the equivalent of just $18 a month – cut in half over the last three years by inflation.

“Health and education are the two toughest sectors in this country,” she said. “They pay you little and you work loads.”

As well as her tiny wage, she cited the piecemeal education her children now receive as another reason for wanting to leave. With a mass exodus of teachers from schools, there’s nobody to teach her 13-year-old twins maths.

State wages in Cuba have plummeted in recent years as “maximum pressure” US sanctions have created massive shortages and stoked runaway inflation. Meanwhile, squeezed public sector workers have more options than before: emigration out of the country is smashing records, while a resurgent private sector hoovers up much of the talent that remains.

The upshot is that the state is suffering an unprecedented brain drain: health and education, long seen as the “pillars” of the Revolution, are fraying as qualified personnel empty out.

Children walk to their classrooms on their first day of school in Havana on 4 September.
Children walk to their classrooms on their first day of school in Havana on 4 September. Photograph: Yamil Lage/AFP/Getty Images

At a school for autistic children in the capital’s Vedado neighborhood, director Elsa Escalona, 72, has lost 13 teachers over the last two years. Four have emigrated to the US – two with undergraduate degrees, two with master’s degrees. She’s had to increase class sizes from the recommended five to nine students per class.

“You feel impotent because there’s no way to convince people to stay,” said Escalona, who just about gets by on her and her husband’s state salaries. “Some teachers have cried because they haven’t wanted to leave, but the economic situation is overwhelming – they feel they need to go.”

Cuba invests more in health and education than any other Latin American country, and Cubans have for decades benefited from results in these sectors comparable to developed countries. But official figures show the number of doctors, nurses and dentists is falling sharply. In October, the ministry of education announced it was 17,278 teachers short.

Two years ago, the government allowed Cubans to incorporate businesses and import goods. Since then, the private sector, long reined in by the Communist party, has roared back and now employs more than a third of the island’s workforce, according to economists. Small and medium-sized businesses, which pay many times more than the state and can employ up to 100 people, are guzzling up many of the best and brightest.

In addition, a new layer of US sanctions, implemented by Trump and largely kept in place by Biden, have succeeded in their stated aim of starving the Cuban economy of hard currency. Economists say the new measures cost the island’s economy billions of dollars a year. Caked on to a botched currency unification three years ago, the economic damage wrought by the pandemic and a highly dysfunctional planned economy, they have created a perfect storm.

A nurse treats the patients at the 19 de Abril hospital, in Havana.
A nurse treats the patients at the 19 de Abril hospital, in Havana. Photograph: Anadolu/Getty Images

“The conditions under which the government is operating are impossible,” said Emily Morris, a development economist at University College London. “These new sanctions have caused a severe decline in living standards. Given that one of the effects of sanctions is to obstruct the government’s access to international finance, there’s nothing else they can do because they have no foreign exchange cushion.”

The government of Raúl Castro eliminated the need for an exit visa to leave the island in 2013, putting an end to half a century of drastic limitations on travel. Up until then, Cubans had to jump through bizarre bureaucratic hoops to legally migrate: inspectors were often sent to people’s homes to tally up knives, forks and spoons and would only issue papers if cutlery tallied with the number on record.

And over the past two years, more than 400,000 Cubans – about 4% of the island’s population – have emigrated to the US. To address the crush of migrants on the southern border, the Biden administration this January unveiled a “humanitarian parole programme” through which Cubans, Venezuelans, Nicaraguans and Haitians with a sponsor can apply from their countries to live and work temporarily in the US.

More than 50,000 Cubans have already arrived through the programme.

Once they’re in the US, Cubans get a “jump start”, according to Susan Eckstein, professor of sociology at Boston University. Of the four nationalities eligible for the new parole programme, she said, Cubans are the only ones for which it serves as a path to lawful permanent residence. “Cubans also automatically qualify for welfare,” she added.

Cubans queue to enter the US embassy in Havana on 4 January.
Cubans queue to enter the US embassy in Havana on 4 January. Photograph: Adalberto Roque/AFP/Getty Images

The relative ease with which Cubans can make it into the US and the unique entitlements they have once they get in, analysts say, are a testament to the power of the Cuban American lobby, which enjoys special influence as it’s rooted in the politically important state of Florida.

In a primary school in Havana’s Marianao neighbourhood, teacher Fernando Rodríguez – who asked to use a pseudonym for fear of reprisals – is feeling despondent. Free school meals for all students are still holding up, but all seven of the school’s computers are broken and there’s a shortage of pencils, erasers, textbooks – and teachers.

Since term started just three months ago, three of his colleagues have already left.

Ideally, he said, he would like to keep working as a teacher: he sees his job as important for future generations and loves how his students become his friends as they grow up.

But his monthly salary now only stretches to buy a few dozen eggs on the black market.

“My dream,” he said, “is to emigrate.”


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *